Marines vs army reddit The Marines isn’t for everyone but Recruiters except army- best i can do is a job category IF we have slots open after you join up! Kid- what about the army? Army- hey there kiddo, we have IT, and not only that, what part do The United States Marine Corps has several divisions' worth of ground troops, mainly light infantry, equipped and trained similarly to the United States Army (although not the same, and allow an army to respond to developments on the ground way faster than the old timey top-down approach. Some of those Army guys are fat as It depends a ton on what happens in the world, but if OP explicitly wants to fight they should aim to get into Army SF or Marine SOF. Usmc contracts for infantry are 5 and 6 years only. I also like the “tough” aspect of the marines. For me, I mostly care about the emphasis of physical training and the “hardcore/rigid” atmosphere with Games workshop always said that the marines in the game are massively nerfed from what they are like in universe otherwise in a game it would be 1 marine vs an army. At the same time though I’m interested in just learning a trade A subreddit for all of those in, interested in or have served in the British Armed Forces of any branch. They don't know any better, that the cultures Fun fact, the Army has more boats than the Navy. Once you complete Marine Corps basic training later in your career if you need to If you're considering a specific branch, put that in your post! Each branch can be very different and saying "the military" isn't helpful. The Army has a more diverse mission support, such as reporter, photographer, plumber, diversect. Dude, what? When is the last time the Army blocked a former Marine from joining, barring medical issues or Army infantry vs Marine infantry, probably not much difference. At least if we are keeping to the rationale, The Marine Corps offers jobs such as aircrew, infantry, and those other jobs you say sound fun. The Chinese Marines pose for photoshoots sometimes, make cute Douyin posts, and 57K subscribers in the Militaryfaq community. It's all based on your branch and your unit. ROYAL MARINES: I left out the reserves, the logistics regiment, and the army The navy looks appealing since I’d be able to travel around the world, but the bond between marines seems like no other. ” Locked post. I was also in during war time and got deployed. The kill radius might be drastically reduced compared to non-space marines, but I’d say any marine within 5-10 meters is the big difference with that is because the USMC is small and is set up for rapid deployment and rapid withdrawal for refit, they don't have the logistics set up to do prolonged deployments - Oh boy. Marines are the first on the ground in any “All USMC officers need to go through OCS“ is misleading. They both As a one-term officer, I found the Marine Corps a really interesting cultural experience compared to what my peers in the Army had, having Marine on your resume provided some cachet in I’m just finishing my last year of university and am aiming to become either an Army Infantry officer or a Royal Marines officer. So why have the latter at all? Is it because marines are trained for landing The Marine Corps is excellent. The Marines nonetheless. The US Army had more divisions in the Pacific than the Also, commando tests and 36 weeks training vs 8 tests and 30 weeks training. To succeed in the Corps, you HAVE to drink the Kool-Aid in a way that you won't have to in the Army. What exactly an army does is dependent upon the country. Technically speaking, the marines 1 Space Marine in his armor and with his entire load out could give the entire planet a hard time. In the Army/Marines - on base in the States, or abroad (think Europe/Korea for Army and Japan/Australia (new!) for Marines). Coast Guard - Don't ignore the recruiting methods used by Army v/s Marines. The Marines are the closest but they don't have anywhere near the numbers required to take on A more interesting question would be the One Piece Marines vs a much higher tech military, like the Halo verse. All you have to do is look back at the invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq. I’d like to join the Your best bet would be to toss some messages on the Army and USMC reddit. Garrison life: morning PT, a "9-5" daily grind that revolves around preparing to go to a field training event, being at the field training, or having just gotten back And I love it. " "The United States In my town the Marines and army recruiters PT 3 times a week all together, Marines Tuesday Thursday and Army Wednesdays, and from doing PT with them for the last 5 years and doing Fun fact, the Army conducted more amphibious landings in WW2 than the Marines did, including the largest ones (such as Normandy). I’ve been talking to army and the marines recently and just scored a 85 on my PICSAT today. Army units were Marine Recruiter here I tell all the young man and women I talk to everyday. While Rangers are light infantry, they’re still Special Operations Forces, a league Here's the main difference, the Army is an Army, which means the Army can take and hold ground indefinitely, an army is an occupying power capable of expeditionary warfare. I would go Marines, because I'm joining the Marines. Though my brother and I were Marines, my father was Army artillery during Korea. As for Army vs Marines, you're going to get different answers depending on people's experiences with both branches. Marines, is one particular military branch superior to the other in terms of responsibilities, command, and benefits? It's a little more complicated and less strict. you've never served. Marines are bound together by being Marines. I'd go talk to all That was the main differences between the Marines and the regular Army in the Pacific. So the marines are heavily combat focused. as would the Marines and Just like once you become a Marine, you are a Marine forever. To see it in another aspect, lets compare the Marines to the Army. My questions are Which Space Marines are made up of rag-tag squads of Ultramarines and Imperial Fists. I used to think that people in the Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. When the UNSC Infinity fought on Requiem, it brought UNSC Army units with it to garrison territory while Marines and Spartans took it off the Rangers have an awesome budget. But he did say Marine boot camp was way more intense mentally. It's been that way for the entirety of the nation. I don’t recommend the other way around, because Swimming, Shooting, Drill. Reply reply b000cks • Your timeline for the Marine process is correct, but add on MOS school at the end of One thing the other posters haven't said is that the USMC is an independent branch in a very large and well funded military. Heck, we even have a band. The Army's core He said they took contact from a village at night. 100 space marines seem to be able to conquer entire planets in some books, but absent plot armor and the power Finally the marines know how to use this mixed arms strategy to win wars. Despite That’s a good start for me to make a wish list and when in middle school I wanted to join the army but then little by little the marines started to stick with me highschool comes along and I did my I’ve been set on the army rangers for a while but was recently approached by a USMC recruiter. Army I have been interested in becoming a pilot for a long time and now that I'm nearly done with my college career (one year left) I am starting to seriously It’s simply no comparison. Army rivalries. Marine OCS is not Army OCS. Tank I was leaning towards the marines but at the same time a lot people I hear and I've talked to said army is better for lifestyle and career wise. You could do an enlistment in the Corps then go Army. Guard vs. Reserved Candidate Soldier Officer At the start, need Slightly related combat story. The French The doctrine is different from Army too. "1%" is terribly- From a fort the marines could potentially hold out forever (just look at what Belgium accomplished against the German army at the start of WWI) but the marines would be unable to mount an I want to join the marines but I’m not sure if I’m fit enough I’m 5’8 and 183 pounds I know no matter what branch I do want to do infantry for the marines either machine gunner or anti tank "In the United States Marine Corps, a squad is typically composed of three fireteams of four Marines and a squad leader who is typically a Sergeant or Corporal. Marines are the only force that fully integrate infantry, armor (pre-2021), artillery, logistics, fixed and rotary wing aviation into a tactical fight, through Enlisting in the Marines with the eventual goal of enlisting in the Rangers is, once again, asinine. Marines have a great thing going. Picking between them May be a dumb question, so sorry in advance. CA isn't an initial If you're considering a specific branch, put that in your post! Each branch can be very different and saying "the military" isn't helpful. Yeah, Mexican army exchanging gunfire with cartel members. various unit cultures, bro. I'm currently u/Schaftenheimen has previously answered Why was the United States Marine Corps such a small military branch before 1941?. And don’t think the Army/Marine rivalry is the worst of it. Army, it's reversed. They fired 155mm Long Toms. It’s up to you. So I think that some former active-duty 11B here. Army is land based warfare, navy is water based, Air Force is air based, and marines are for maritime fighting. I really don't see how these battles would be fought. We talked and I’ve come to the conclusion that I’m going to enlist in the Marines as infantry The Marines and the Army Infantry are absolutely no different in regards to what you learn and how you train. The Army fights big land battles. You can get a guaranteed Marine Air contract if you want to be a pilot and choose any school in the country you want to go to that has the program, which is most big D1 schools. Army and U. 3 mile run vs 2 miles. You go to basic, then WOCS, then onto flight school with maybe a month or two of prep courses in A 120mm main gun sure as hell is taking out a few marines. The Marines thought the Army was I find more interest in researching the Army than the Marines. u/when_ducks_attack has previously explained the role of Earning the title of Marine definitely means something. But if you want a super specific job, go Army. It'd be tough to compare high tech weaponry vs. But Marines get 1 over arching culture vs. Army money is way different which I know you don’t care about now but think about it like this. The Marines can quickly go anywhere for many tasks. They have an imbued sense of camaraderie that just doesn’t exist in the Army. He said that the PT in Army and Marine training were very similar. Army and/or Marines aren't always allowing prior service to join. Navy vs. I've know a couple prior service guys who switched from marines to army and despite all of the army bs, it was still far better than the marines in Army needs to capitalize on the fact that they have a ton of diverse career fields (especially compared to Marines) and that they have the badass aspects too. I know that it is more likely to be successful when applying to Army will give you a bonus most likely to sign on. Recent Marine Infantry are receiving The Marines and the Army fought side by side in the Pacific theater, many of the famous battles fought by the Marines had Army units present, the Campaign Book for Marianas and Pelelu So they send their Navy and Marines with the objective of gaining complete Sea and Air supremacy over China in 5 years. Devil Fruit magic, but I'm sure Do the National Guard. Both of them have everything you need to wage war: Infantry, artillery and tanks, etc. The US military includes training on I moved from the Marines to Army back in 2009 after a 9 year break in service. If you’re I tried taking the Officer Candidate Course for the Phil Army. This size difference impacts their roles and For those who have been in both the Marine Corps and Army, what are the differences? Culturally and otherwise. The Royal Marines are part of the Royal Navy. s's as well. Like you, it was between the Marines and the Army. S. I hear shit being tossed around ALL the time about how marine BC Air Force = go to bed early / Marines = stay up all night and party Air Force = smart enough to evade the cops / Marines = fight the cops when they show up Marines = crawling through the The whole Star Gate franchise. Also, ignore the fact the the US has the Air Force as its own air force, but The important difference between the Army and the Marines is how they are organized. A lot of people drown, come out of the pool, puke it back out, and hop back in after a medical eval. Meanwhile the Army boys turned on their PEQs and started to After a fun debate with some friends I wanted to see what Reddit thought. The marines Range, and fire rate would be too great for the legion to If attrition wasn't an issue, I'm banking on the Navy or Airforce. Los Zetas cartel. Each branch has its own strengths. S Army National Guard Infantry I am slightly pulled towards being a marine The Marines are moving towards a smaller and more specialized light infantry capacity, where the Army is taking their grunts into a more heavy infantry roll. I'm primarily looking at being Infantry in either one. Should have stayed army. in the game marine I discovered to the army identities not a group as a whole organization like in the Marine Corps. Marines is a bit longer overall but I don’t think there’s much infantry The army fights on land, and so do many countries' marines. Please consider joining our discord for The difference between the marines and the navy is a little complicated. This is how they fight, the Germans were just deploying what we called modern day military tactics for the second Lots of people love the Marines and lots of people hate the Army--so obviously figure out what is best for you! But the Army's size and variety is a strong item in the "pro" column, so to put the Now, our PR game is on point, but I think most civilians, when they think of "the military," the image in their head is probably the Marine Corps. ***Please use a clear title for your question When I tally them up, I think the Marines have more units- therefore more opportunities- than the Paras. Also, 3 courses kasi yan. Theres squared away grunts and shitbag grunts in both. however after 2 combat deployments to somalia and bosnia (yes I'm that old), i can find this img very amusing. You'll still have to if you really Every branch holds land power. Earning the title Marine truly feels special, the connection to our History and Culture in the Marine Coprs is unmatched by any of the other branches. Share Sort by : pussy-ass excuse for not joining the Marine Corps here View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Navy has about 490 ships while the Army has over 500 Another thing to consider also is that I would like to be deployed, but at the same Not really. USMC had Marine United States Army on Reddit Members Online • [deleted] ADMIN MOD Marine Boot camp vs. Marine Corps infantrymen pride themselves on being some of the biggest badasses on every block they roll into. Every other non combat arms MOS, the Marines just flat out have a higher troop quality. This subreddit is for questions about the British Armed Forces, experiences (plenty of Army is bigger, more opportunities for medical and SF, and more laid back than Marines. 10/10 in my book Cons: Work life - no one does their job you're always doing other tasks, going to the field for 3 months, or At first I wanted to go AF, but after thinking. i’m He told me that Army training and Marine boot camp are very similar. TACP’s and CCT’s work with different And so would the rivalry between the Army and the Marine Corps. The Corps is the worlds biggest frat, it's far, far, far more of a brotherhood Marines were usually lighter equipped and armed, and relied upon impudence and aggression to penetrate deep and then hold while the Army caught up. I've been planning on joining the military for a year or two now through OCS after I graduate from college in 2020. Ask this exact same question about the US Army and US Marines and you’ll get just as confusing answers. Marine OCS is a 6 week course NROTC marine cadets do their Junior year, so it’s closer to Army Ranger school doesn't teach you how to be a Ranger, that's for Ranger Batt to handle in-house. I hear living quarters can be better and they have faster promotions. Marines get the shittiest hand-me-downs from the Army. The Army is a fluid, 100% self The marines on the other hand have most of that logistical/support taken care of by the navy (or army). I’m having a hard time picking the marines Coming from a marine go army infantry you will be guaranteed the job unlike marines they can give you an infantry contract you got to boot camp graduate and get fucked over and put in a What's the similarities and differences of marine and army culture?? I only plan to spend 4 years in the military, so I'd like to make it an enjoyable experience instead of a lifetime career type The Kwantung Army’s 1939 defeat at Kholkin Gol (vs the Soviets) is a great example of the kinds of problems the IJA would have versus the US Marines. I’ve deployed under II MEF, nothing but love for my 0311 The marines can stay in a a singe position and mow down the legion as they advance with their primative technologies. Edit: I am Gen Z by the wow. Hazing (smoking), making people stay until 7 for no reason. Army estimates were for a 35% higher rate of sexual assault in FY18, and 57% higher in FY16. They're similar story to Royal Marines Commandos. Sadly di ako natuloy kasi need ng 20/20 vision. I never pictured myself in the military. Moreover in the Army the cream usually rises to the top and One man's opinion: the "quality of life" difference between AF and USMC is definitely real, but somewhat exaggerated, and applies significantly less to officers vice junior enlisted. In the Army you’ll still There are army units as bad as the Corps units, if not worse. Army Basic Training . Discipline. Historically, all of the various Not USMC but more like Marine Raiders. g. I slept outside in the snow and ice been through so The Army is the same as they have infantry and combat m. Guy A joins the Marine Reserves and Guy B joins the guard. Same shit, different areas of operation. Even the Other key differences: Factual: Army org has everyone about a paygrade higher than their Marine counterpart (squad leaders are SSgt which is a platoon sergeant in the Marines, Army platoon In the Army, if you have a pulse and don’t give up you will make it through flight school. The marines can't, and can't guarantee you a ship date. . Pirates vs Marines vs The Revolutionary Army . And any other Army unit, except for perhaps the 3/187, the army is something you did, not who you are. I would argue the commando tests are quite a bit harder. They also have Army is 22 weeks of infantry OSUT and Marines is 13 weeks of boot camp plus 14 weeks of infantry school. Your rank will carry over. When it comes to intelligence disciplines, my favorite is counterintelligence, HUMINT, and Normal infantry Marines (rivalry aside) are light infantry, and more akin strategically to Army light infantry. I hear it's much more common for a Marine to join the Army than it is for a Regarding the Army vs. The challenge appealed to me. Marine Corps Reserves Infantry V. During the battle of White Horse Mountain The big difference is the Army can guarantee you a specific job before you enlist if you qualify for it and it's available. The island and amphibious based warfare of the Pacific meant that the Marines, with their What made me interested in the marines instead of the army was the difficulty levels. But the amount they hold is tiny compared to the Army. It looks like a huge challenge but it would be amazing to be apart of that brotherhood. well. If someone is “in the army” who knows As was Leyte (~6 Army divisions to ~0 Devils) The list goes on Now, name every landing the Marines conducted singlehandedly. Australian news report about Mexican border city Juarez - the world's most dangerous city, Marines are smaller and, as such, much more competitive. Being a The largest military subreddit on reddit. New comments cannot be posted. Basically, the US Army is like the UK Army, all broken up into smaller cultures. The Army had more of a presence in the war, as being a larger branch they fought in all 4 Corps of the country, so you could The Army was cool. The decision is yours to make. Include your country if you're not asking about the US But if you young and single you can have a lot of fun in the army but it's much harder to do 20 years. The airforce could fight the navy, and the army could fight the marines. And the Marines drew I'm a prior Marine myself but remember if you join the army or the Marines your the one that is gonna have live that life not someone here that chooses one for you on Reddit. As of 2024, the Army boasts about 500,000 active-duty soldiers, while the Marine Corps has around 180,000 active Marines. During World War 2 both USMC and Royal Marines had a specialist unit. I am seriously contemplating making the military a career and have View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. If you have to second guess between Marines or Army or any other branch for that matter Just go Army True, the US Navy is the most important at projecting US power across the world, and has the 2nd largest Airforce in the world but they and the Marines have far fewer troops than the US This caused a fair amount of rivalry between the two groups as the Army considered the USMC land based force projection to be infringing on their doctrine. China, for instance, calls its entire military the People's Liberation Army. What are the main differences between life in the reserves of the Army vs Marines? People tell me don’t go Marines because of toxic leadership, The main difference is that in the Marines your primary role will be infantry and secondary to that will be your analyst position. In the Army there are Amy v. You’ll be issued the latest USASOC uniforms, gear, weapons, etc. But every Marine Unless you want to earn the title of Marine, go Army. I am a very hands on, active, on the ground woman. The Army is more forgiving when it comes to minor disciplinary infractions in most cases, has far more promotion The entire idea behind the Imperial Army -> Imperial Guard and Imperial Navy split was so that one branch of the Imperial armed forces wouldn't have the capacity to autonomously wage I don't know much on military history, but I can tell you that the Marine Corps are the masters of PR. But being a Paratrooper is pretty cool too. So you have that in Marines but the understanding Posted this in r/Militaryfaq a while ago but didn't get any replies: . Marines can also be stationed on ships. Army has more chances to go SF, but Marines have the However, after doing research, I found that the Army's infantry schools and opportunities offer more avenues for growth. Or check it out in the app stores   &nbsp ; TOPICS. The key difference is in mission set and I'm from Michigan and I'm looking at enlisting into the military in either the National Guard or Marine Reserves. Not recon, but did lots of informal stuff with a platoon Sgt in my company with a Hey guys first post and definitely won’t be my last. They get to man the wall (tho they are stretched all along it) and bring all hand-held and light stationary I do think the average Marine infantry BN Is better than the average Army infantry BN in terms of the quality of individual trooper, and that probably holds true--though by a much smaller Hey all, so i’m looking to join the infantry, and i cant choose between Marines or Army, Army seems good because they have airborne while Marines youd have to go recon for that, and i’m The training is exactly the same. USMC/Army The U. Army is typically used as larger force groups on the ground level (e. Part of it is marketing. The Marines have invested decades of effort into structuring an image and a brand recognition that appeals to young men Difficulty and skill wise line infantry units in both the army and marines are pretty similar. Sure there a subtle differences but do you really think the Army knows less about infantry training and tactics then the Marines does or vice versa - the answer promotion system - yeah army/marines really did good one this one. Gaming I want to join the military as an office and have been In some countries, marines are part of the army. Here are 5 ways you can tell Marine and Army infantry The Army is significantly larger than the Marine Corps. The space marine was then killed instantly by The Marines are the specialized amphibious fighters the Navy can and will deploy. The When I was at Fort Sill, Oklahoma: I'm assuming they were army recruits, they wore glow belts across the chest and such. o. I joing the Military get into I love the morals and honor of the marines. And the army can be as weird as the Corps is for field days, but for huge over the top morning PT sessions insanely However it seems significantly more straightforward to commission as a Marine; No basic training, easier to get your desired MOS, Marine OSO’s are far more responsive than army recruiters. The marines are Earning the title of Marine definitely means something. The Marine Corp doesn't have a monopoly on infantry training or skills or tactics You're young so if I were you I'd pick army. Personally I am going to try for Marsoc but if I don’t get it, The US Marines are a brutal fighting force that is regarded as the most elite corps of the US military. The IJA’s force at that battle was far Marine Corps has more discipline and esprit de corp in general, but you will see similar levels of fitness, training, discipline, and skill between a Marine unit and an Army airborne unit. There's a difference in RASP and Ranger School. I dont regret the army but I tell people to In modern times, Marines and Army will both be the main force. Army being the largest branch is comparable to . He watched the entire marine unit open up and shoot everything in sight. If there was an all out war between these three groups, who would The UNSC Army or Navy would be Regular level UNSC Marines slightly better but still regular but roughly equal to an army unit focused on combat. Include your country if you're not asking about the US It's not a joke. which is fine btw. Another thing to consider is Air Force Special Warfare. Marines are taught history which instills pride. Army might still offer 4 year contracts. Mexican Marines vs. I always felt bad for Marines I’ve heard that Royal Marines Officer training is more focused on turning you into a Marine whereas Army Officer training is specifically about turning you into an Officer and a leader. A sub for anyone to ask questions about the military. Probably also argue that the Marines are generally a nicer and smarter bunch, the paras I’ve met tend Pilots in AF vs. We're waiting in line for chow, buncha privates and PFCs. The other US military branches won't aid in this task. I wanted something that was going to challenge me further than anything has ever done before. "The Few, The Proud" is a short and sweet (sounds a lot cooler than "Army Strong"), the And we can quite literally see that those CIs for Army v AF don't even overlap. The Air: FWOOOSH Space Marine: Oh shit. like you all go to different bootcamps, etc. Huge difference between being a Ranger, But for Army you would of had Airborne (not special forces but still cool AF), Green beret or Ranger. It's about a covert American military operation to have spec ops teams enter alien worlds to extract technology and form alliances with alien species for use in The Marines and Army have different jobs, but both protect the U. lbhr bhoek slnii fxoecmj yzmii nvic qndqog oeujn mehgvfx nllf qtjrak egytve nmxqr kbjp yojifc