Silnylon vs silpoly cost. With tarps, you need a taught pitch.
Silnylon vs silpoly cost How much does it cost to hike Te Araroa? Cuben Fiber vs Silnylon vs Silpoly December 13, 2020 Merino vs Synthetic vs Cotton SilNylon. Main downside is its expense. Silpoly. Oct 23, 2024 · COST - Silnylon tents are produced in larger quantities, benefiting from production efficiency. But for the true ultralight purists, silnylon still reigns supreme, with 10-denier options that are lighter than any silpoly on the market. Compare weight, durability, breathability, cost, and more to determine the ideal fabric for your thru-hiking needs. Aug 28, 2020 · The conventional wisdom is that nylon is substantially stronger, but that consensus seems to have started from unfair comparisons that pit a silnylon vs a PU poly (where the sil tilts the playing field towards nylon) and thus isn’t nearly as true for silnylon vs silpoly (or even sil versus other PU formulations like PEU). DCF does not like that! I started to see tiny holes in mine after a year. It is generally believed that nylon is not as resistant to UV as polyester, but according to our tests, polyester is only slightly stronger than nylon, unless the fabric is thickened, no 15D material of the same thickness will last 90 days continuously under Silpoly doesn't soak up much water and has solid UV resistance. The silpoly versions are less expensive (as cheap as $100 for the Mongar 2p), have way better water resistance and won't sag in the rain and have better uv resistance. 5: Some/Most of the 20d silpoly and 20d silnylon availble to DYI’ers though resellers are not as good as the ones used by some tent manufacturers. Nylon 6. More typically used as basic rain wear. 1 silpoly, what are the pros and cons of one over the other? 10-28-2018, 19:48 Nov 3, 2023 · 2. I've recently been doing a fair amount of MN winter camping with my trusty MJ tarp, which I lovebut last weekend it was SUPER windy and although my MJ held strong, I've decided I want a tarp with doors for added protection from the cold winter wind. It definitely does not grow much when wet, and consequently does not need re-tightening. Joined Jul 2, 2020 Messages 50. Considering your budget is important when deciding between Dyneema and Silpoly tents, as the cost difference between them is considerable. Thread starter Sverimerica; Start date Oct 11, 2018; Oct 11, 2018 #1 S. i would like to see them do a silpoly motrail as it is their lightest, simplest singlewall 2p shelter and, more importantly, budget friendly. Dcf tents are very light. MLD comes with a sil bag already. Due to the difficulty of sourcing and laminating an appropriate mylar layer, no other manufacturer has managed to make something as light and strong to create cost competition. This is basically a ripoff of the Durston Xmid 2p, but inferior silnylon vs silpoly, does not come seam sealed and costs much more. Mar 1, 2023 · Cost: Name-brand DCF is expensive. Meanwhile silpoly is less than 1/2 of the price and DCF is a pain to have to fold every time you want to put it away, plus it takes up a lot more room than They do pack a little large, and cost a lot more than silpoly. This is then called Silpoly. It’s winter down here which means daily rain and long nights, I’m quite impressed. Jul 22, 2024 · The ripping in wind was interesting. Oct 19, 2024 · Discover the pros and cons of silnylon, silpoly, and DCF tent materials. Like, I'd trust a 20d silnylon that Ron tested and selected against, e. 1 oz silnylon or silpoly. Thread starter nednic; Start date Apr 13, 2021; Apr 13, 2021 #1 nednic FNG. Joined Jul 9, 2018 Messages 3,100 Likes 14,511. Cuben tarps are lighter than silnylon or silpoly tarps, but much, much more expensive. Silnylon doesn't hold creases like silpoly does. Nov 18, 2011 · Sil-nylon is great as a tarp, but not very abrasion resistant so its a no go for a groundcloth. Oct 15, 2023 · The choice between Silnylon and Silpoly will depend on your specific requirements, whether you prioritize minimal sagging or want additional tear resistance. Silpoly is a waterproof fabric made from polyester, while silnylon is a lightweight nylon material with a silicone coating that adds water resistance to the fabric. Silnylon and silpoly aren't waterproof like that, IMO to put meat in and not get some leakage. The silnylon tents cost more, weigh less and have a higher tear strength than silpoly. Enjoy SilNylon stretches and wets out or soaks in some water when it rains which requires the use of some shock cord guy lines to keep the tarp taught. Be it silnylon or silpoly. I have several Hammock and ground tarps in 30D SilNylon, and a Warbonnent ThunderFly in 20D SilPoly. Silnylon it better at dealing with tears, but they can both tear. 5 ' x 7. How much does it cost to hike Te Araroa? Cuben Fiber vs Silnylon vs Silpoly December 13, 2020 Merino vs Synthetic vs Cotton Nov 16, 2020 · The cost of the thru-hike was underestimated (sometimes significantly). But given that silpoly has the better UV resistance, there’s no reason to believe that it would fail quicker than silpoly. g. What is the cost difference of a 7x9 silpoly/silnylon vs a 7x9 DCF tarp, like $200? For me, that’s worth it. "If reputable manufacturers can save cost AND add performance, then they certainly will and silnylon will be obsolete. In this video, we dive deep into the results of our recent tent fabric field test. 5' die, 7. UV slowly destroys the material and soaks up more water. Polyester is the best choice for a higher waterproof rating, but if that is not an issue, silnylon is lighter, stronger and stretchier. Now we’re talking about cost being a major factor, so it depends on how much you’re willing to spend. It also doesn’t pack down as small as other fabrics, taking up precious space in my pack. Silpoly doesn't absorb as much water. The following information refers to the Silnylon that we formerly offered. Dyneema is the most durable fabric available in the market, but its price stays among the highest. Silpoly: Key Differences. Sil nylon stretches ( a bit ) , sags ( a bit ) , and will absorb a tiny TINY bit of water. Mar 30, 2023 · 4: Some 20d silnylon stretches way less than some 20d silpoly, even when wet. Silnylon is more durable than DCF, which is reported to last 200 nights or so, perhaps more if it is stored correctly. It's bulkier, and harder to pack. The recommendation of the official Te Araroa trust of 7000-10000 NZD (approx. Apr 7, 2024 · Silnylon und Silpoly sind zwei beliebte Optionen, die jeweils ihre eigenen Vor- und Nachteile haben. 75/yard 1. 1 silnylon or 1. Hey guys, would like to make a rain Mar 6, 2022 · In my opinion, sliders tend to wear out much more quickly on DCF tents than on silnylon or silpoly tents because DCF tents are high tension and therefore put a ton of stress on the zipper. Dec 2, 2022 · At $7 to $10 per square metre, SilNylon is the most expensive, followed by PU Nylon at $3 to $5 per square metre and Silpoly at $2 to $3 per square metre. Silpoly doesn't stretch as much so it's a little tougher to get tight pitches, but it doesn't sag when wet and cold, not nearly as much anyway. However, the big manufacturers are still mostly using Silnylon. With tarps, you need a taught pitch. 1 oz Silpoly $6. Indem du deine individuellen Bedürfnisse und Vorlieben berücksichtigst, kannst du das Material auswählen, das am besten zu dir passt. Some hikers had to stop in the middle of the hike because they ran out of money. This company also sells many teepee hot tents. Feb 19, 2023 · For most brands, the differences between silpoly and silnylon are negligible; most use 20-denier or 30-denier fabrics that are about 1. 9oz silnylon [excellent but heavier], the standard cheap silnylon 20D [OK], the 15D silnylon [ too light for a mountain hunt], the 1. Silpoly Vs. 5' silnylon tarp that I adore because it is so packable. 5' tall] from the Sil poly about 8-10 years ago. Nylon, however, is hydrophilic, meaning that it absorbs water over time. Silnylon: Key differences and considerations for backpackers Overall, the best all purpose materials (in my opinion) are either plain 1. Polyester as a fabric does no absorb water, but at the same denier it is not as strong or abrasion resistant as Nylon. Joined Oct 10, 2016 Messages 643 Location Sweden. Please note that we are not currently using Silnylon. For example, the silpoly Tarptent Protrail costs $239, while the DCF version costs $529. 6oz silpoly from RSBTR knowing I was going to use it in harsh environments and wanted more strength. All Jun 8, 2023 · Like Dyneema, UltraTNT is what is known as a composite fabric. 75 less to ship 9 yards of sil to my zip code which I guess shows the difference in packing size between the two. In the case of UltraTNT, that looks like two polyester films sandwiching a grid of Ultra (or ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene) fibers. Mar 11, 2023 · Silpoly: Hilleberg Niak: 5,000 mm: 12,000 mm: although it costs extra and will increase the weight of your tent by an ounce or two. Bulk- DCF doesn't pack down as small as silpoly/silnylon. Oct 24, 2021 · The most significant cause of tent life is UV, which breaks down fabric fibre molecules and subsequently pulverises and breaks them. . I got a very light silpoly for a tarp that I use with hammocking and as a ground family tarp, because I'm never, ever going to test it in a very windy situation. Feb 6, 2021 · Obviously, if one or the other fabric needs replaced more often, that might more than offset any differences in production. If a top end waterproof breathable jacket costs a few hundred dollars, imagine the cost of a tent. 3 after) and is used both for rainflys and floors. Silpoly is not as light as DCF, but it packs down to a smaller size than DCF and silnylon. Jul 2, 2020 · Silnylon VS Silpoly. Silnylon vs. It is a bit weird how slippery it is, especially when trying to stuff it in a stuff sack. Jun 18, 2019 · Silpoly -vs- Silnylon when wet No adjustments were made since the initial setup about 20 hours ago. Dyneema, also known as DCF (Dyneema Composite Fabric), stands on the higher end of the price spectrum. But , depending, I do more camping in a year than most. 6: No one on any forum hardly ever talks about dry stretch on the bias. A couple of disadvantages of DCF that you haven't mentioned. Jan 22, 2025 · Second, what makes it waterproof and breathable usually makes it heavier and weaker. Some pieces of gear are worth it investing the money in. 6 with a silicone coating. 1 silpoly, what are the pros and cons of one over the other? 10-28-2018, 19:48 After owning both, I prefer sil nylon. That’s a 221 percent markup for a tent Apr 17, 2023 · Silpoly and Silnylon are two types of fabrics used for outdoor gear. Budgeting for Adventure: Dyneema vs. Sverimerica WKR. Silnylon. When it comes to tent purchasing, you’ll find that silnylon offers a more budget-friendly option compared to the pricier Dyneema Composite Fabric (DCF) tents, without sacrificing much regarding quality. Having shockcord loops on the tie outs means your tarp will keep better tension and handle the wind much better. ) I totally understand being on a budget (I've read a couple of Dave Ramsey's books and try to follow as best as I can), but I'd personally save up for another month and go with the sil. Jun 21, 2022 · this is great to see. Whether you're an avid backpacker, camper, or outdoor enthusiast, choosing Apr 24, 2022 · Silpoly is less likely to stretch and sag when it rains. I have read to store in a sil nylon bag, which is slippery and less abrasive than DCF. It remains to be seen how durable it will be over the long term, but it seems promising. It doesn't seem to hold as much water either. silpoly: So, what's the big difference anyway? Silpoly has become tremendously popular mainly because it stays taut under load. Jul 9, 2018 · Silpoly vs silnylon? Thread starter 45Smashemflat; Start date Sep 8, 2019; 4. X-mids are the other popular option obvs. All my tarps look like a shanty town, never got them taut. Also the fabric stays more dry than silnylon after rain. Of those three, I choose silpoly. 1 silpoly, what are the pros and cons of one over the other? silnylon vs. 4000-6000 Euro) is rather low. Silpoly Cost Analysis. So on balance, I suspect that Jon is right and silpoly is the greener fabric. Tons of companies are switching like Black Diamond, Nemo, MEC, SMD etc. Thoughts on silnylon vs silpoly for both a camp tarp & hammock tarp? The cost difference is negligible but from a strength, waterproofness and ease of sewing does one hold an advantage over the other? Apr 26, 2024 · 4) Nylon vs Poly There are a lot of differences that can be debated like stretch, strength, cost, how well they dye, how fast they dry, UV etc but I think the one that is the most relevant for real world use is the lack of expansion/sag in poly. ive never had an issue with silnylon except for the sag and the water-weight, and this seems to address both without the bulk and cost of dcf. Warbonnet's silpoly holds up fine in the winter and is the superior option. silpoly debate had me confused for years. I can’t explain sil vs silpoly as I’ve never bothered to have a level of interest to go down that road. , a 30d silnylon from a NatureHike tent. Probably the reverse. I don’t have really expensive gear, but I do have an EE quilt and a DCF 7x9 tarp. Even ones that were originally against it like Tarptent are now switching. 6 is stronger than the more common When given a choice between 1. When given a choice between 1. " Silpoly doesn't save cost, but it does add performance. While silnylon and silpoly are traditional woven fabrics coated in liquid silicone, UltraTNT and Dyneema are laminated. Jul 23, 2024 · I've had the Tents from the 1. 1 ounces per square yard. Also I plan on grabbing a Yama Cirriform Min in silpoly when they are available or maybe an 1 person X-mid if I can to replace my Dyneema shelters as they are getting older. I made a tipi [12. They’re also very hard to get a perfect pitch with if you’re spatially challenged 🥺 and they are so bulky. Avoid high costs in case of an accident. Silpoly is pretty much the same thing as silnylon — just trade out the nylon yarn for polyester. Both of them pack down small, are cheap, and need seam sealing. Dyneema (DCF) Dyneema Composite Fabric (DCF), formerly known as Cuben Fiber, is another popular option for lightweight outdoor gear. This flexibility, similar to a boat’s anchor line, helps absorb shock from strong gusts without straining the fabric, seams, or stakes. While this is relatively new to the tent market, it picks up where silnylon left off and adds some property improvements. Roughtly 6oz for DCF vs 10-11oz for Silpoly of the same size as a percentage it seems like a big difference but either one is going to take a respectable chunk out of your BPW vs a tent. I used the stronger 1. Silnylon absorbs moisture which causes the material to relax, so it looses tautness after setup. silpoly, pros and cons question. It sounds like durability is one of your main questions. 1 oz Silnylon $12. I believe the SilPoly to be a superior material for tarps. 45Smashemflat Guide. It is less tear resistant than silnylon. I got rid of mine for a silpoly lunar solo. I have a sil/nylon/pu Breaking Down the Cost: Dyneema vs. However, with the right technique, it can pack quite small. - Dual vents (vs no vents) - Full coverage fly to block rainsplatter/drafts (vs higher cut fly) - Double wall (vs singlewall) And for space the X-Mid is quite a bit more generous with 92" x 50" floor (vs 81" x 48/42"), more headroom from a longer ridgelilne, and much larger vestibules. It weighs 1. 1 oz/yd 2 prior to coating (about 1. Oct 14, 2014 · for example, i have a 10 x 10 polyeruthane tarp weights almost 2lbs (1lb 13oz) the same size tarp made from silnylon weighs less than a pound (13-14 oz). Only thru hikers rival my outdoor time. Silnylon is more tear resistant than silpoly and exists in larger selection of fabrics. Jan 19, 2019 · 1. Cost, obviously Abrasion/puncture resistance- DCF is more prone to punctures than silpoly/silnylon. [Archive] - Hammock Forums - Hammocks and hammock camping - Elevate Your Perspective Nov 16, 2020 · Avoid high costs in case of an accident. One of the main drawbacks to SilPoly tents is that they tend to suffer from more condensation than either SilNylon or DCF tents. Outdoor ice fishing shacks. Jan 10, 2020 · It is further improved by an additional waterproof coating. The silnylon vs. High stress tends to grind sand into the interior sides of the slider instead of giving the malleable teeth the opportunity to bend around the grains. They have a veraion that you can get with a stove jack and essentially have a "hot tent" Xmid. 95 (but it costs $1. Both materials have excellent durability and strength, making them popular choices for camping tents, backpacks Dec 13, 2020 · Instead of nylon, sometimes polyester is used with the same process. DCF typically adds $200-300 to the price compared to similar silnylon designs. 6oz silpoly [durable, good but heavier] and the higher quality Silnylon 30D which I consider the best all around fabric for the smaller 2-4 man shelters. May 6, 2014 · Silnylon is stronger and doesn't tear as easily. Here is a short video explaining why we prefer Rip-stop Silpoly over Silnylon. Jul 1, 2022 · There are both Polyester and Nylon silicone coated fabrics (Silnylon, Silpoly). Also, a lot hinges on your use case. I strongly prefer silpoly in general, but could see the argument for silnylon on, say, a duomid used for 4 seasons. Sep 8, 2019 #1 It comes down mostly to silnylon vs silpoly construction. The following is a list of advantages and disadvantages. In contrast, DCF tents are often made in smaller batches, which can drive up costs. That said, I have ordered a Borah 7x9 and Bivy in silpoly for myself. Other possible cons (objective) cost increase for silnylon $22. silnylon vs. And I don't consider the added bulk an issue, as my tarp stays on the outside of my pack. I wouldn’t do a silnylon, from what I’ve heard the time they take to dry out even from (frequent) condensation is ugh. i got my poly tarp for around $60 vs the silnylon for my tarp is $125 Seek Outside Silex. Our SilNylon is a 30D Ripstop Nylon 6. Oct 10, 2016 · Silnylon vs silpoly. The complexity of the processing also has an impact on the cost. The trend among homemade tents and tarps is slowly moving more towards Silpoly due to some very positive properties. Jan 7, 2025 · While we recognize silpoly’s advantage like minimal sag in rain and decent UV resistance, we find that silnylon’s elasticity gives our tents a critical edge in windy or turbulent weather. 50/yard Perhaps the silpoly is more expensive to manufacture? I had only guessed the costs must be lower because for like shelters, for example comparing the old JimmyTarps Hudson (silpoly) to a Seek Outside Cimarron (silnylon), Seek was charging quite a bit more. Just sewed up a 9x9 silpoly tarp and from my initial setups, i gotta say that the bit of stretch in silpoly makes it pitch much nicer than silnylon with a bit of fudge room on the guyline geometry. I have a 9. Third, the cost of these fabrics is very high, and a comfortably sized winter camping hot tent uses a LOT of fabric, which would drastically increase the cost. For casual campers or those who don’t require ultra-lightweight gear, silnylon tents offer a great balance of performance and affordability, making them a practical Aug 24, 2020 · Yes, that would be a tarp. jtak gofwb qzbxqvis enxob wsdk jvh pvngb ciroz zao vkxopf